Prevention of exposure to and spread of COVID-19 using air purifiers: challenges and concerns

Seunghon Ham

doi:10.4178/epih.e2020027

Articles

Page Path: HOME > Epidemiol Health > Volume 42; 2020 > Article

COVID-19 Perspective Prevention of exposure to and spread of COVID-19 using air purifiers: challenges and concerns: Seunghon Ham; Epidemiol Health 2020;42:e2020027.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4178/epih.e2020027
Published online: April 17, 2020

Department of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, Gil Medical Center, Gachon University College of Medicine, Incheon, Korea

Correspondence: Seunghon Ham Department of Occupational and Environmental Medicine, Gil Medical Center, Gachon University College of Medicine, 21 Namdong-daero 774beon-gil, Namdong-gu, Incheon 21565, Korea E-mail: shham@gachon.ac.kr

• Received: April 1, 2020 • Accepted: April 16, 2020

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

prev next

26,329 Views
1,369 Download
32 Web of Science
27 Crossref
40 Scopus

Full Article

Download PDF

Abstract
Ethics statement
NOTES
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
REFERENCES

Abstract

Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) is now a pandemic. The Korean government has declared a red alert, which is the highest level of the national infectious disease alert system, and the World Health Organization has similarly declared its highest-level pandemic alert (phase 6). The spread of COVID-19 is an unprecedented worldwide public health problem that governments and individuals must work to overcome. Recently, an infection cluster arose in a call center in Seoul. To support call center companies, the Korean Ministry of Employment and Labor has proposed covering the costs of installing partitions and air purifiers, providing hand sanitizers, and supplying masks to prevent droplet and aerosol infections. Air purifiers are expected to be installed on the floor with the exhaust outlets at a higher level, such as the level of the desks or breathing zones of workers. When a worker coughs or releases droplets near a colleague’s respiratory system, the droplets may spread throughout the call center via air flow from air purifier. In this fashion, a single infected person can give rise to an infection cluster. Attempts to prevent infection must not lead to new infections, and the installation of air purifiers may cause new problems. Therefore, using air purifiers to control the spread of COVID-19 should be approached with caution.
Keywords: COVID-19, Air purifier, Occupational disease, Infection cluster, Call centers, Occupational health

The first case of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) in Korea was confirmed on January 20, 2020. On February 23, 2020, the Korean government issued a red alert (the highest level of the infectious-disease alert system according to the Korea Centers for Disease Control and Prevention), and on March 11, 2020, the World Health Organization issued a pandemic alert of the highest level (phase 6). COVID-19 has become a global issue, and international cooperation is currently crucial [1-4].

Since the original primary focus of interventions against COVID-19 was the prevention of community infection, the development of policies to prevent infection from occupational exposure has been neglected. A recent outbreak in a Seoul call center exemplifies occupation-related disease, as it was caused by occupational exposure to a biological hazard. Due to the nature of the job, workers at the call center interacted extensively in a high-density space, increasing the probability of infection. In addition, the work environment likely contributed to the infection cluster in that taking breaks during business hours at a call center is rare, which made it more difficult for the workers to seek treatment.

As of March 16, 2020, Korea’s Ministry of Employment and Labor proposed to pay 20 million won to more than 1,100 small and medium-sized call center companies with fewer than 50 full-time workers to cover the costs of installing partitions and air purifiers and providing hand sanitizers and masks for the prevention of droplet and aerosol infection. This seemed to be an appropriate measure to protect the health of workers in crowded call centers.

However, using air purifiers without considering the heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) system of the facility may expose call center workers to new risks. The use of air purifiers is not an appropriate approach to control COVID-19 at call centers for the following reasons.

First, air purifiers use a dilution ventilation method, which reduces the concentration of harmful substances in the air, while diluting particulate matter (such as fine dust) or gaseous substances (such as volatile organic compounds). Diluted ventilation is widely used due to its low toxicity, low emission rate, and high effectiveness for gaseous substances, and it is used when the substances are produced uniformly over time or when the installation of a local exhaust ventilation system is difficult. The virus that causes COVID-19 is a highly contagious, small, and a biological hazard that is still not fully understood. Therefore, air purifiers employing dilution ventilation are unsuitable. Methods of controlling biological hazards such as COVID-19 are, from most to least effective, elimination, substitution, isolation, engineering control (ventilation), administrative measures, and the use of personal protective equipment (PPE). To prevent community infection, the most feasible option is to recommend the use of PPE, even though this is less effective than other methods; however, call centers can be adequately managed through the proper application of isolation and ventilation.

The second challenge is posed by the air dispersion methods of such air purifiers. Most air purifiers function by directing pollutant-containing air downwards to capture it, passing the air through a filter, and discharging the purified air back into the surroundings. Since the purified air must be discharged at a greater distance from the purifier than its intake, the wind speed is stronger at the outlet than at the inlet. Therefore, since relatively strong air flow is present at the outlet, the pressure difference causes the air to rise and disperse into the surroundings at a location farther away or positioned higher than the inlet.

A pilot experiment showed that the flow of water mist into an air purifier inlet depended on the height of the source (Figure 1). Air purifiers are relatively complex because of the structure of the air flow involved. Figure 1A and 1B illustrates the flow of water mist into an air purifier inlet. Of note, when the height of the water vapor source was increased, the water vapor did not flow into the inlet of the air purifier. Instead, the air flow in the exhaust zone was disturbed due to the strength of the outflow (Figure 1C and 1D). The distance of the water vapor from the air purifier inlet made the efficiency lower than expected. The exhaust of the air purifier had a relatively high wind speed, with a maximum of approximately 10 m/s. In light of these findings, it may be possible to distribute air without filtering out the virus that causes COVID-19. Considering that most air purifiers are installed at the floor level, the installation of air purifiers to limit the spread of COVID-19 seems to have more drawbacks than advantages. This experiment was a pilot study and therefore had several limitations, including the use of water mist to mimic and visualize the droplets, the lack of evaluation of a variety of air purifiers, and the need to replicate the experiment. Nevertheless, given that COVID-19 is an urgent social and public health issue that requires debate, I believe that this pilot experiment was sufficiently meaningful to start a discussion.

Since the government only covers installation costs for air purifiers and does not provide detailed research-based guidelines, most air purifiers will likely be installed on the floor, not at the desk level. If a worker coughs or releases droplets in close proximity to the face of a co-worker, the droplets could disperse throughout the space of the call center via the air flow. In this fashion, one infected person can give rise to an infection cluster.

Therefore, to prevent COVID-19 spread in call centers, control at the source is most effective since anyone may be infected. Potential control measures include the modification of existing partitions into a booth configuration or the installation of simple booths with preinstalled local exhaust ventilation systems. This partitioning can be compared to the sudden drop in the suction power of a vacuum cleaner with an increase in distance. The distance between inlet and the pollutant is the one of most important aspects of ventilation theory. It is necessary to implement a design that does not inconvenience workers, and considering the social impact of asymptomatic infected individuals, this effort should be undertaken by the government, employers, and workers.

In addition, various factors warrant further research, such as filter effectiveness and efficiency, air purifier sterilization capacity, and the transmission of the virus through HVAC systems. Other measures to prevent COVID-19 infection are appropriate, such as installing partitions, providing hand sanitizers, and supplying mask by Ministry of Employment and Labor in Korea; however, the installation of air purifiers may not be suitable and should be approached with caution, as measures designed to prevent infection should not lead to new infections.

Ethics statement

This paper is a perspective so it did not need ethical consideration.

NOTES

CONFLICT OF INTEREST

The author has no conflicts of interest to declare for this study.

FUNDING

This work was supported by the Basic Science Research Pro gram of the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF), funded by the Ministry of Science, ICT & Future Planning (2017R1-C1B1002717).

AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS

All work was done by SH.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

None.

Figure 1.

Pilot experiment result of visualized air flow in terms of height of source (A) floor level, (B) 8 cm, (C) 16 cm, and (D) 24 cm from floor level.

REFERENCES

1. Ki M. Epidemiologic characteristics of early cases with 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) disease in Korea. Epidemiol Health 2020;42:e2020007.Article PubMed PMC PDF
2. World Health Organization. Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic. [cited 2020 Mar 19]. Available from: https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019.
3. World Health Organization. Statement on the second meeting of the International Health Regulations (2005) Emergency Committee regarding the outbreak of novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV); 2020 Jan 30 [cited 2020 Mar 19]. Available from: https://www.who.int/news-room/detail/30-01-2020-statement-on-thesecond-meeting-of-the-international-health-regulations-(2005)-emergency-committee-regarding-the-outbreak-of-novel-coronavirus-(2019-ncov).
4. Gan WH, Lim JW, Koh D. Preventing intra-hospital infection and transmission of COVID-19 in healthcare workers. Saf Health Work 2020;doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.shaw.2020.03.001.Article

Figure & Data

References

Citations

Citations to this article as recorded by

A CFD study on the effect of portable air cleaner placement on airborne infection control in a classroom
Gen Pei, Parham Azimi, Donghyun Rim, Joseph G. Allen
Environmental Science: Processes & Impacts.2024; 26(9): 1476. CrossRef
Smart sanitization on a budget: revolutionizing public transport hygiene post-COVID
J. Dinesh Peter, D. Raveena Judie Dolly, D. J. Jagannath, S. Allen Livingston
Frontiers in Public Health.2024;[Epub] CrossRef
Prediction of Air Purifier Effectiveness for Eliminating Exhaled Droplets in a Confined Room
Yumeng Zhao, Alexander Russell, Kingsly Ambrose, Carl R. Wassgren
Processes.2024; 12(9): 1917. CrossRef
Application of nanotechnology in air purifiers as a viable approach to protect against Corona virus
Ali Mahmoudi, Seyedeh Belin Tavakoly Sany, Marzieh Ahari Salmasi, Ali Bakhshi, Arad Bustan, Sahar heydari, Majid Rezayi, Fatemeh Gheybi
IET Nanobiotechnology.2023; 17(4): 289. CrossRef
Indoor Air Purifiers in the Fight against Airborne Pathogens: The Advantage of Circumferential Outflow Diffusers
Yevgen Nazarenko, Chitra Narayanan, Parisa A. Ariya
Atmosphere.2023; 14(10): 1520. CrossRef
Portable Air Purifiers’ Predicted Efficacy in Mitigating Airborne Pathogen Transmission in an Office Room Featuring Mixing Ventilation
Xiangdong Li, Milan J. Patel, Ivan S. Cole
Fluids.2023; 8(12): 307. CrossRef
The effect of an air purifier on aerosol generation measurements during clinical motility testing
Wout Verbeure, Annelies Geeraerts, I‐Hsuan Huang, Lien Timmermans, Joran Tóth, Hannelore Geysen, Louise Cools, Florencia Carbone, Jolien Schol, Herman Devriese, Rico Haesaerts, Hideki Mori, Tim Vanuytsel, Jan Tack
Neurogastroenterology & Motility.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
COVID-19 and air purifiers use
Beuy Joob, Viroj Wiwanitkit
International Journal of Preventive Medicine.2022; 13(1): 47. CrossRef
Transforming healthcare through a digital revolution: A review of digital healthcare technologies and solutions
Nithesh Naik, B. M. Zeeshan Hameed, Nilakshman Sooriyaperakasam, Shankeeth Vinayahalingam, Vathsala Patil, Komal Smriti, Janhavi Saxena, Milap Shah, Sufyan Ibrahim, Anshuman Singh, Hadis Karimi, Karthickeyan Naganathan, Dasharathraj K. Shetty, Bhavan Pras
Frontiers in Digital Health.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
The Influence of Plastic Barriers on Aerosol Infection Risk during Airport Security Checks
Shengwei Zhu, Tong Lin, John D. Spengler, Jose Guillermo Cedeño Laurent, Jelena Srebric
Sustainability.2022; 14(18): 11281. CrossRef
Internet-of-nano-things (IoNT) driven intelligent face masks to combat airborne health hazard
Vishal Chaudhary, Akash Gautam, Poonam Silotia, Sumira Malik, Roana de Oliveira Hansen, Mohammad Khalid, Ajit Khosla, Ajeet Kaushik, Yogendra Kumar Mishra
Materials Today.2022; 60: 201. CrossRef
SARS-CoV-2 airborne transmission: a review of risk factors and possible preventative measures using air purifiers
Mahshab Sheraz, Kaleem Anwar Mir, Ali Anus, Van Cam Thi Le, Seungdo Kim, Van Quyet Nguyen, Woo Ram Lee
Environmental Science: Processes & Impacts.2022; 24(12): 2191. CrossRef
Influenza and Influenza Vaccine: A Review
Cynthia Nypaver, Cynthia Dehlinger, Chelsea Carter
Journal of Midwifery & Women's Health.2021; 66(1): 45. CrossRef
Airborne transmission of virus-laden aerosols inside a music classroom: Effects of portable purifiers and aerosol injection rates
Sai Ranjeet Narayanan, Suo Yang
Physics of Fluids.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
Application of Portable Air Purifiers for Mitigating COVID-19 in Large Public Spaces
Zhiqiang (John) Zhai, He Li, Robert Bahl, Keith Trace
Buildings.2021; 11(8): 329. CrossRef
Societal Changes Due to “COVID-19”. An Analysis of the Tourism Sector of Galicia, Spain
Noelia Araújo-Vila, Jose A. Fraiz-Brea, Alexandra Matos Pereira
Sustainability.2021; 13(15): 8449. CrossRef
Effects of Air Purifiers on the Spread of Simulated Respiratory Droplet Nuclei and Virus Aggregates
Ki Joon Heo, Inyong Park, Gunhee Lee, Keejung Hong, Bangwoo Han, Jae Hee Jung, Sang Bok Kim
International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health.2021; 18(16): 8426. CrossRef
Improved estimates of 222 nm far-UVC susceptibility for aerosolized human coronavirus via a validated high-fidelity coupled radiation-CFD code
Andrew G. Buchan, Liang Yang, David Welch, David J. Brenner, Kirk D. Atkinson
Scientific Reports.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
Genomic Variations in the Structural Proteins of SARS-CoV-2 and Their Deleterious Impact on Pathogenesis: A Comparative Genomics Approach
Taj Mohammad, Arunabh Choudhury, Insan Habib, Purva Asrani, Yash Mathur, Mohd Umair, Farah Anjum, Alaa Shafie, Dharmendra Kumar Yadav, Md. Imtaiyaz Hassan
Frontiers in Cellular and Infection Microbiology.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
Reducing indoor particle exposure using mobile air purifiers—Experimental and numerical analysis
Adrian Tobisch, Lukas Springsklee, Lisa-Franziska Schäfer, Nico Sussmann, Martin J. Lehmann, Frederik Weis, Raoul Zöllner, Jennifer Niessner
AIP Advances.2021;[Epub] CrossRef
The CO2 assessment in a school classroom for an optimal natural ventilation strategy = The CO2 assessment in a school classroom for an optimal natural ventilation strategy
Patricia Guijarro Miragaya, Tania Estay Leal, Lucia Patrón Saade, Ricardo Tendero Caballero
Building & Management.2021; 5(3): 29. CrossRef
Use of antimicrobial mouthwashes (gargling) and nasal sprays by healthcare workers to protect them when treating patients with suspected or confirmed COVID-19 infection
Martin J Burton, Janet E Clarkson, Beatriz Goulao, Anne-Marie Glenny, Andrew J McBain, Anne GM Schilder, Katie E Webster, Helen V Worthington
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews.2020;[Epub] CrossRef
Antimicrobial mouthwashes (gargling) and nasal sprays to protect healthcare workers when undertaking aerosol-generating procedures (AGPs) on patients without suspected or confirmed COVID-19 infection
Martin J Burton, Janet E Clarkson, Beatriz Goulao, Anne-Marie Glenny, Andrew J McBain, Anne GM Schilder, Katie E Webster, Helen V Worthington
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews.2020;[Epub] CrossRef
Antimicrobial mouthwashes (gargling) and nasal sprays administered to patients with suspected or confirmed COVID-19 infection to improve patient outcomes and to protect healthcare workers treating them
Martin J Burton, Janet E Clarkson, Beatriz Goulao, Anne-Marie Glenny, Andrew J McBain, Anne GM Schilder, Katie E Webster, Helen V Worthington
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews.2020;[Epub] CrossRef
COVID-19: What do we know?
Steve Marshall, Michael Duryea, Greg Huang, Onur Kadioglu, James Mah, Juan Martin Palomo, Emile Rossouw, Dina Stappert, Kelton Stewart, Eser Tufekci
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics.2020; 158(5): e53. CrossRef
How chemical engineers can contribute to fight the COVID-19
Harrson S. Santana, Marcos R.P. de Souza, Mariana G.M. Lopes, Johmar Souza, Renan R.O. Silva, Mauri S.A. Palma, Wilson L.V. Nakano, Giovanni A.S. Lima, Guadalupe Munhoz, Dirceu Noriler, Osvaldir P. Taranto, João L. Silva
Journal of the Taiwan Institute of Chemical Engineers.2020; 116: 67. CrossRef
Analysis on Applicability of Air Purifiers in Schools to Prevent the Spread of Airborne Infection of SARS-CoV-2
Bangwoo Han, Sang-Bok Kim, Gunhee Lee, Gi-Jeong Hong, In-Yong Park, Hak-Joon Kim, Ye-Wan Lee, Yong-Jin Kim, Sang-Hyeon Jeong, Seong-Hoon Shim, Jin-Tae Kim, Seon-Ah Roh, Tae-Jin Min, Wan-Ho Shin
Journal of Korean Society for Atmospheric Environment.2020; 36(6): 832. CrossRef

PubReader
ePub Link
Cite

CITE

export Copy Format

Close

XML Download

Figure

Prevention of exposure to and spread of COVID-19 using air purifiers: challenges and concerns

Figure 1. Pilot experiment result of visualized air flow in terms of height of source (A) floor level, (B) 8 cm, (C) 16 cm, and (D) 24 cm from floor level.

Figure 1.

Prevention of exposure to and spread of COVID-19 using air purifiers: challenges and concerns