Abstract
-
OBJECTIVES
- Previous studies have estimated the risk of death associated with unemployment in the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, but no studies have examined unemployment before COVID-19 infection as a risk factor for COVID-19-related mortality. Thus, this study aimed to investigate COVID-19 mortality among this population.
-
METHODS
- Data on 50,038 people aged 25-59 years were collected from 38 agencies in Fars Province, Iran, from February 2020 to July 2021. Follow-up lasted from participants’ diagnosis with COVID-19 based on the results of a reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction test to participants’ death or the end of the study period. The association between unemployment and COVID-19-related mortality was estimated using the Poisson regression method, and a sensitivity analysis was conducted to calculate the E-value.
-
RESULTS
- Unemployment was associated with a 2.41-fold (95% confidence interval [CI], 2.01 to 2.90) higher age-adjusted and sex-adjusted risk of COVID-19-related mortality. The adjusted Poisson regression analysis showed 8.82 (95% CI, 6.42 to 12.11), 2.84 (95% CI, 1.90 to 4.24), and 1.58 (95% CI, 1.24 to 2.01) times higher risks of COVID-19-related mortality among unemployed people aged 25-39 years, 40-49 years, and 50-59 years, respectively, than among their employed counterparts. Unemployment increased the risk of COVID-19 mortality by 3.31 (95% CI, 2.31 to 4.74) and 2.30 (95% CI, 1.86 to 2.84) times in female and male, respectively. The E-value was 3.43, reflecting the minimum strength of confounding required to shift the association between unemployment and COVID-19-related mortality toward the null.
-
CONCLUSIONS
- Unemployment prior to COVID-19 infection increased the risk of COVID-19-related mortality. COVID-19-related mortality disproportionately impacted unemployed women and younger unemployed people.
-
Keywords: Unemployment, COVID-19, Mortality, Iran
INTRODUCTION
- Approximately 35 million coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) infections have been recorded worldwide, resulting in more than 610,000 estimated deaths by August 2021 [1]. COVID-19 may disproportionately affect unemployed people due to economic distress and the deferment of care [2,3], leading to an excess in mortality. Several recent studies have shown that deaths attributed to COVID-19-related unemployment have disproportionately varied by sex, age, race and ethnicity, and education level [3-5]. These studies have suggested that different policy decisions during the COVID-19 pandemic, including universal masking, community-wide lockdowns, social distancing, travel restrictions, quarantine, stay-at-home orders, and contact tracing, were effective tools for reducing COVID-19 transmission and mortality [6-8], but also cause a decline in economic growth [9,10], which substantially impacted health and human well-being [11,12].
- Despite previous studies estimating the risk of death associated with unemployment related to the COVID-19 pandemic [3-5], no studies have examined COVID-19-related mortality among those who were unemployed prior to COVID-19 infection. Moreover, although the association between unemployment, poor health, and increased mortality seems robust [13,14], whether the association between unemployment and mortality is causal remains an open question. Chronic diseases could be mediating or confounding variables in the association between unemployment and mortality, meaning that chronic diseases could be caused by adverse behavioral changes related to unemployment or could be a shared cause of both unemployment and mortality.
- In the current study, we aimed to address 2 questions. First, given that prior studies have observed an association between unemployment (or losing one’s job as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic) and mortality, we examined whether those who were unemployed before the COVID-19 pandemic (rather than as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic) and were infected with COVID-19 had higher mortality than that of employed people. Second, we assessed the predicted associations among subgroups of the study participants based on their chronic disease status since chronic diseases may have been mediating or confounding variables.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
- Data and study population
- For this study, data were collected from 38 state agencies and combined for research purposes at a medical care monitoring center (MCMC) storage facility in Fars Province in southern Iran from February 2020 to July 2021. The MCMC is a system for reporting COVID-19 cases in hospitals according to the instructions of Iran’s health ministry. Using this system, data on admission, diagnosis, treatment regimens, and follow-up for each patient are collected. In Fars and throughout Iran, data on hospitalized patients are recorded using a health information system and paper-based medical records (details on the MCMC system, its data quality, and its quality assurance can be found in a study by Zarei et al. [15]). Individuals aged 25-59 years were included in the study to account for nearly all working-age people. The follow-up period began at the time of diagnosis with COVID-19 based on a reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction test or computed tomography scan findings and ended either when the subject died or when the study period ended. A small percentage (0.01%) of individuals were excluded due to a lack of information on their employment status. A total of 50,038 subjects were ultimately included in the final study population.
- Exposure, potential mediating or confounding variables, and outcomes
- The study population was categorized into 2 groups (employed and unemployed) according to their exposure status, and COVID-19-related mortality was defined as the outcome. Unemployment was defined as having no income for at least a year preceding the COVID-19 pandemic. Moreover, demographic data, data on sex and age, and data on comorbid diseases (coded as 1= yes and 0= no for each chronic disease), including on diabetes, cancer, cardiovascular disease, pulmonary disease, chronic kidney disease, and HIV, were also collected by the MCMC system.
- Statistical analysis
- Descriptive statistics were used to define the categorical variables, and risk ratios and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were obtained using the Poisson regression method with a robust standard error. All analyses were performed using Stata version 14 (StataCorp., College Station, TX, USA). Using the multiple Poisson regression method, we estimated the age-adjusted and sex-adjusted risk ratios for the association between unemployment and COVID-19-related mortality. We then repeated this procedure for each chronic disease, since they functioned as effect modifiers or mediating factors rather than as confounding variables concerning the association of interest in this study. Since the outcome of interest was binary, we used log-Poisson regression models to estimate valid risk ratios in addition to robust standard errors to correct the related standard errors obtained from the Poisson models (a detailed explanation of the log-Poisson regression model and robust standard error for binary outcomes can be found in a study by Mansournia et al. [16]) as follows:
- In which β is the coefficient of the predictor variables and log(π) is the logarithm of the risk.
- Sensitivity analysis
- We computed the E-value, which indicates the minimum strength of unknown or unmeasured confounding variables needed to fully explain the association between unemployment and COVID-19-related mortality beyond the measured confounders on the risk ratio scale [17], as follows:
- Ethics statement
- The protocol of this study was reviewed and approved by the Ethics Committee of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences (code: IR.SUMS.REC.1399.1165).
RESULTS
- Out of the 50,038 participants aged 25-64 years, 1,838 (3.7%) were unemployed. Of the employed participants, 938 (1.9%) died, while 148 (8.0%) of the unemployed subjects died. The demographic characteristics and medical histories of participants in relation to COVID-19 deaths are summarized in Table 1.
- The age-sex-adjusted Poisson regression indicated that unemployed participants had a 2.41 (95% CI, 2.01 to 2.90) times higher mortality risk than those who were employed. The age-adjusted risk ratio of mortality was 3.31 (95% CI, 2.31 to 4.74) for unemployed female compared to employed female and 2.30 (95% CI, 1.86 to 2.84) for unemployed male compared to employed male. For those aged 25-39 years, 40-49 years, and 50-59 years, the risk ratios of mortality were 8.82 (95% CI, 6.42 to 12.11), 2.84 (95% CI, 1.90 to 4.24), and 1.58 (95% CI, 1.24 to 2.01), respectively, for unemployed participants compared to employed participants in the same age groups. This study showed that unemployment increased the risk of COVID-19-related mortality in nearly all of the subgroups under investigation. The risk ratios for the association between employment status and COVID-19-related mortality according to chronic disease subgroups are shown in Table 2. The sensitivity analysis indicated that an E-value of at least 3.43 was required for the adjusted risk ratio of 2.41 to shift the association between unemployment and COVID-19-related mortality toward the null.
DISCUSSION
- This study examined the association between unemployment and COVID-19-related mortality among working-age people in the province of Fars in southern Iran. Our findings demonstrated that, although the risk of COVID-19-related mortality increased with age, it was substantially higher among younger unemployed participants than among younger employed participants in the corresponding age groups than older unemployed participants compared to older employed participants. Older unemployed people may tend to have more financial resources and savings when they lose a job, making younger unemployed people more vulnerable to financial stress, which can lead to deferred care and increase their risk of COVID-19-related mortality. Future studies should examine this phenomenon further.
- The results of the present study showed that unemployed female were more likely to die from COViD-19 infection than employed female, and the magnitude of this difference was greater than that between unemployed and employed male. Due to socioeconomic and cultural factors in Iran [18,19], females are more likely to have part-time jobs and lower wages than males; as a consequence, job loss may pose more economic distress for female, which would make it harder for them to afford the cost of COVID-19 treatment. The long-term effect of COVID-19-related job loss on mortality seems to be worse for female than for male [5], whereas the opposite findings have been observed related to the short-term effect [3]. A cohort study conducted by d’Errico et al. [20] found an unemployment-mortality association in males, while no association was detected in females. Although a few studies have investigated mortality associated with COVID-19-related unemployment [3-5], no previous studies have examined COVID-19-related mortality among those who were unemployed prior to COVID-19 infection.
- The present study found that unemployment increased the risk of COVID-19-related mortality in nearly all of the chronic disease subgroups, but the strength of the association varied according to the chronic disease, which suggests that chronic diseases functioned as effect modifiers or mediating factors rather than as confounding variables concerning the association of interest in this study. A robust literature analysis found that the association between unemployment and mortality was most likely a causal relationship [14,21]. Therefore, unemployment may be a proxy for other factors such as low socioeconomic status, poor nutrition, and weak social support that affect COVID-19-related outcomes, including mortality, even though healthcare services related to COVID-19 are free of cost according to public health policy in Iran.
- There were several limitations to our study. First, unemployment is associated with other factors related to high mortality, such as economic distress. Therefore, the lack of data on the participants’ precise income level and health insurance status may have distorted the results of our study. Well-designed cohort studies have observed a consistent poverty-mortality relationship, with each extra US$10,000 of annual income potentially reducing mortality by over 50% [22]. Second, no information on the participants’ education level, family size, duration of unemployment, social support system, and amount in savings was included in the MCMC cohort data, and further studies are needed to account for the effects of these variables on the association between unemployment and COVID-19-related mortality. Nonetheless, the sensitivity analysis yielded an E-value of 3.43, indicating the magnitude of confounding that would be required to shift the association between unemployment and COVID-19-related mortality toward the null.
- In conclusion, this study adds new insights to the existing body of work on this topic. Unemployment prior to COVID-19 infection was found to increase the risk of COVID-19-related mortality. COVID-19-related mortality also disproportionately burdened unemployed female and younger unemployed people.
NOTES
-
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare for this study.
-
FUNDING
None.
-
AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS
Conceptualization: Aryaie M. Data curation: Dadvar A, Moradian MJ. Formal analysis: Aryaie M, Mirahmadizadeh A. Funding acquisition: None. Methodology: Mirahmadizadeh A, Badeleh Shamooshaki MT, Aryaie M. Project administration: Mirahmadizadeh A. Visualization: Badeleh Sshamooshaki MT. Writing – original draft: Mirahmadizadeh A, Badeleh Shamooshaki MT, Dadvar A, Moradian MJ, Aryaie M. Writing – review & editing: Aryaie M.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We would like to express our gratitude to the MCMC staff for their helpful collaboration in both data collection and data cleaning.
Table 1.Demographic characteristics, medical history, and risk ratio in relation to coronavirus disease 2019 deaths in 50,038 participants
|
Characteristics |
Subjects, n |
Death, n (%) |
Crude |
Adjusted |
|
Entire cohort |
50,038 |
1,086 (2.2) |
|
- |
|
Sex |
|
|
|
|
|
Female |
27,150 |
476 (1.7) |
1.00 (reference) |
- |
|
Male |
22,888 |
610 (2.7) |
1.52 (1.35, 1.71) |
- |
|
Age (yr) |
|
|
|
|
|
25-39 |
29,227 |
268 (0.9) |
1.00 (reference) |
- |
|
40-49 |
11,913 |
275 (2.3) |
2.51 (2.13, 2.97) |
- |
|
50-59 |
8,898 |
543 (6.1) |
6.65 (5.76, 7.68) |
- |
|
Employment status |
|
|
|
|
|
Employed |
48,200 |
938 (1.9) |
1.00 (reference) |
1.00 (reference) |
|
Unemployed |
1,838 |
148 (8.0) |
4.13 (3.50, 4.88) |
2.41 (2.01, 2.90) |
|
Chronic disease status |
|
|
|
|
|
No chronic diseases |
42,705 |
564 (1.3) |
1.00 (reference) |
1.00 (reference) |
|
At least 1 chronic disease |
7,333 |
522 (7.1) |
5.38 (4.79, 5.06) |
3.10 (2.68, 3.58) |
|
Diabetes |
|
|
|
|
|
No |
47,669 |
913 (1.9) |
1.00 (reference) |
1.00 (reference) |
|
Yes |
2,369 |
173 (7.3) |
3.81 (3.25, 4.46) |
1.84 (1.56, 2.18) |
|
Cancer |
|
|
|
|
|
No |
48,936 |
958 (2.0) |
1.00 (reference) |
1.00 (reference) |
|
Yes |
1,102 |
128 (11.6) |
5.93 (4.98, 7.06) |
3.96 (3.29, 4.76) |
|
Cardiovascular disease |
|
|
|
|
|
No |
47,107 |
901 (1.9) |
1.00 (reference) |
1.00 (reference) |
|
Yes |
2,931 |
185 (6.3) |
3.30 (2.82, 3.84) |
1.55 (1.31, 1.83) |
|
Pulmonary disease |
|
|
|
|
|
No |
49,194 |
1,037 (2.1) |
1.00 (reference) |
1.00 (reference) |
|
Yes |
844 |
49 (5.8) |
2.75 (2.08, 3.63) |
1.77 (1.34, 2.34) |
|
Chronic kidney disease |
|
|
|
|
|
No |
49,292 |
1.016 (2.1) |
1.00 (reference) |
1.00 (reference) |
|
Yes |
676 |
70 (9.4) |
4.55 (3.61, 5.73) |
2.64 (2.07, 3.35) |
|
HIV |
|
|
|
|
|
No |
49,572 |
1.066 (2.1) |
1.00 (reference) |
1.00 (reference) |
|
Yes |
466 |
20 (4.3) |
1.99 (1.29, 3.07) |
1.49 (0.96, 2.30) |
Table 2.Risk ratios for the association between employment status and coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19)-related mortality by subgroup among 50,038 participants
|
Variables1
|
Unemployed, n (%) |
Crude |
Adjusted for mortality2
|
|
Sex |
|
|
|
|
Female |
362 (1.3) |
5.51 (3.93, 7.73) |
3.31 (2.31, 4.74) |
|
Male |
1,476 (6.4) |
3.37 (2.77, 4.09) |
2.30 (1.86, 2.84) |
|
Age (yr) |
|
|
|
|
25-39 |
632 (2.2) |
9.87 (7.29, 13.25) |
8.82 (6.42, 12.11) |
|
40-49 |
414 (3.5) |
3.02 (2.05, 4.44) |
2.84 (1.90, 4.24) |
|
50-59 |
792 (8.9) |
1.58 (1.25, 2.01) |
1.58 (1.24, 2.01) |
|
Chronic disease status |
|
|
|
|
No chronic diseases |
1,209 (2.8) |
3.78 (2.88, 4.95) |
1.89 (1.42, 2.53) |
|
At least 1 chronic disease |
629 (8.6) |
2.28 (1.84, 2.81) |
2.19 (1.75, 2.73) |
|
Diabetes |
|
|
|
|
No |
1,690 (3.5) |
4.47 (3.73, 5.35) |
2.56 (2.10, 3.13) |
|
Yes |
148 (6.2) |
1.85 (1.18, 2.89) |
1.72 (1.08, 2.73) |
|
Cancer |
|
|
|
|
No |
1,685 (3.4) |
4.16 (3.47, 5.00) |
2.32 (1.90, 2.83) |
|
Yes |
153 (13.9) |
1.43 (0.95, 2.15) |
1.48 (0.95, 2.30) |
|
Cardiovascular disease |
|
|
|
|
No |
1,627 (3.4) |
3.96 (3.27, 4.80) |
2.23 (1.80, 2.75) |
|
Yes |
211 (7.2) |
3.11 (2.22, 4.35) |
2.96 (2.07, 4.25) |
|
Pulmonary disease |
|
|
|
|
No |
1,788 (3.6) |
4.26 (3.59, 5.05) |
2.48 (2.05, 2.99) |
|
Yes |
60 (7.1) |
1.48 (0.61, 3.60) |
1.18 (0.48, 2.92) |
|
Chronic kidney disease |
|
|
|
|
No |
1,750 (3.5) |
4.02 (3.36, 4.80) |
2.31 (1.90, 2.81) |
|
Yes |
88 (11.8) |
2.39 (1.45, 3.95) |
2.38 (1.42, 3.98) |
|
HIV |
|
|
|
|
No |
1,823 (3.7) |
4.18 (3.54, 4.95) |
2.43 (2.02, 2.93) |
|
Yes |
15 (3.2) |
1.58 (0.22, 11.07) |
1.33 (0.21, 8.31) |
REFERENCES
- 1. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. COVID-19 case surveillance public use data profile [cited 2021 Oct 1]. Available from: https://data.cdc.gov/Case-Surveillance/COVID-19-Case-Surveillance-Public-Use-Data-Profile/xigx-wn5e.
- 2. Brenner MH. Will there be an epidemic of corollary illnesses linked to a COVID-19–related recession? Am J Public Health 2020;110:974-975.ArticlePubMedPMC
- 3. Matthay EC, Duchowny KA, Riley AR, Galea S. Projected allcause deaths attributable to COVID-19-related unemployment in the United States. Am J Public Health 2021;111:696-699.ArticlePubMedPMC
- 4. Bhatia R. Predictions of Covid-19 related unemployment on suicide and all-cause mortality. medRxiv 2020;[Preprint]. [cited 2021 Oct 1]. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.05.02.20089086.Article
- 5. Bhatia F, Bianchi G, Song D. The long-term impact of the COVID-19 unemployment shock on life expectancy and mortality rates (No. w28304); 2021 [cited 2021 Oct 1]. Available from: https://www.nber.org/papers/w28304.
- 6. Ebrahim SH, Ahmed QA, Gozzer E, Schlagenhauf P, Memish ZA. Covid-19 and community mitigation strategies in a pandemic. BMJ 2020;368:m1066.ArticlePubMed
- 7. Li R, Pei S, Chen B, Song Y, Zhang T, Yang W, et al. Substantial undocumented infection facilitates the rapid dissemination of novel coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2). Science 2020;368:489-493.ArticlePubMedPMC
- 8. Pan A, Liu L, Wang C, Guo H, Hao X, Wang Q, et al. Association of public health interventions with the epidemiology of the COVID-19 outbreak in Wuhan, China. JAMA 2020;323:1915-1923.ArticlePubMedPMC
- 9. Eichenbaum MS, Rebelo S, Trabandt M. The macroeconomics of testing and quarantining. J Econ Dyn Control 2022;138:104337.Article
- 10. Hall RE, Jones CI, Klenow PJ. Trading off consumption and COVID-19 deaths (No. w27340); 2020 [cited 2021 Oct 1]. Available from: https://www.nber.org/papers/w27340.
- 11. Ferguson NM, Laydon D, Nedjati-Gilani G, Imai N, Ainslie K, Baguelin M, et al. Impact of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) to reduce COVID-19 mortality and healthcare demand; 2020 [cited 2021 Oct 1]. Available from: https://www.philipcaputo.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Imperial-College-COVID19-NPI-modelling-16-03-2020.pdf.
- 12. Gordon SH, Sommers BD. Recessions, poverty, and mortality in the United States: 1993–2012. Am J Health Econ 2016;2:489-510.Article
- 13. Roelfs DJ, Shor E, Blank A, Schwartz JE. Misery loves company? A meta-regression examining aggregate unemployment rates and the unemployment-mortality association. Ann Epidemiol 2015;25:312-322.ArticlePubMedPMC
- 14. Roelfs DJ, Shor E, Davidson KW, Schwartz JE. Losing life and livelihood: a systematic review and meta-analysis of unemployment and all-cause mortality. Soc Sci Med 2011;72:840-854.ArticlePubMedPMC
- 15. Zarei J, Dastoorpoor M, Jamshidnezhad A, Cheraghi M, Sheikhtaheri A. Regional COVID-19 registry in Khuzestan, Iran: a study protocol and lessons learned from a pilot implementation. Inform Med Unlocked 2021;23:100520.ArticlePubMedPMC
- 16. Mansournia MA, Nazemipour M, Naimi AI, Collins GS, Campbell MJ. Reflection on modern methods: demystifying robust standard errors for epidemiologists. Int J Epidemiol 2021;50:346-351.ArticlePubMedPDF
- 17. VanderWeele TJ, Ding P. Sensitivity analysis in observational research: introducing the E-value. Ann Intern Med 2017;167:268-274.ArticlePubMed
- 18. Moradi G, Mostafavi F, Hajizadeh M, Amerzade M, Mohammadi Bolbanabad A, Alinia C, et al. Socioeconomic inequalities in different types of disabilities in Iran. Iran J Public Health 2018;47:427-434.PubMedPMC
- 19. Modarresi M, Arasti Z. Cultural challenges of women entrepreneurs in Iran. In: Rezaei S, Li J, Ashourizadeh S, Ramadani V, Gërguri-Rashiti S, eds. The Emerald handbook of women and entrepreneurship in developing economies. Bingley: Emerald Publishing; 2021. p 229-245.
- 20. d’Errico A, Piccinelli C, Sebastiani G, Ricceri F, Sciannameo V, Demaria M, et al. Unemployment and mortality in a large Italian cohort. J Public Health (Oxf) 2021;43:361-369.ArticlePubMedPDF
- 21. Lundin A, Lundberg I, Hallsten L, Ottosson J, Hemmingsson T. Unemployment and mortality--a longitudinal prospective study on selection and causation in 49321 Swedish middle-aged men. J Epidemiol Community Health 2010;64:22-28.ArticlePubMed
- 22. Woolhandler S, Himmelstein DU. The relationship of health insurance and mortality: is lack of insurance deadly? Ann Intern Med 2017;167:424-431.ArticlePubMed
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
- How do socioeconomic determinants of health affect the likelihood of living with HTLV-1 globally? A systematic review with meta-analysis
Nydile Ramesh, Beatrice Cockbain, Graham P. Taylor, Carolina Rosadas
Frontiers in Public Health.2024;[Epub] CrossRef - Is there a relationship between internet access and COVID-19 mortality? Evidence from Nigeria based on a spatial analysis
Richard Adeleke
Dialogues in Health.2023; 2: 100102. CrossRef - Determinant Factors of Mortality in Pre-elderly and Elderly Patients With COVID-19 in Jakarta, Indonesia
Thresya Febrianti, Ngabila Salama, Inggariwati, Dwi Oktavia
Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health.2023; 56(3): 231. CrossRef - The gamma-Maxwell regression for COVID-19 mortality rates of the 50 U.S. largest cities
N.S.S. da Costa, G.M. Cordeiro
Model Assisted Statistics and Applications.2023; 18(3): 193. CrossRef
KSE
, Mohammad Taghi Badeleh Shamooshaki2
PubReader
ePub Link
Cite
XML Download
